Quick
Search: 
 
advanced search
 GSW Home    GeoRef Home    My GSW Alerts    Contact GSW    About GSW    Journals List    Help 
Economic Geology Don't get GSW? Talk to your librarian.
JOURNAL HOME HELP CONTACT PUBLISHER SUBSCRIBE ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS

Economic Geology; January 2005; v. 100; no. 1; p. 63-86; DOI: 10.2113/100.1.0063
© 2005 Society of Economic Geologists
This Article
Right arrow Abstract
Right arrow Full Text
Right arrow Full Text (PDF)
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Right arrow Citation Map
Services
Right arrow Email this article to a friend
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in ISI Web of Science
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrow reprints & permissions
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via ISI Web of Science (3)
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Wilkinson, J. J.
Right arrow Articles by Boyce, A. J.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
GeoRef
Right arrow GeoRef Citation

Ore-Forming Processes in Irish-Type Carbonate-Hosted Zn-Pb Deposits: Evidence from Mineralogy, Chemistry, and Isotopic Composition of Sulfides at the Lisheen Mine

J. J. Wilkinson{dagger} and S. L. Eyre*

Department of Earth Science and Engineering, Royal School of Mines, Imperial College London, Exhibition Road, London SW7 2AZ, United Kingdom

A. J. Boyce

Scottish Universities Environmental Research Centre, East Kilbride, Glasgow G75 0QF, Scotland


Figure 006401
View larger version (55K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 1. Simplified geologic map of the Irish Midlands, showing location of major deposits.

 

Figure 006502
View larger version (30K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 2. Summary stratigraphy of the Lisheen area (modified after Eyre, 1998).

 

Figure 006603
View larger version (41K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 3. Simplified structural map of the Lisheen deposit, showing main ore zones and locations of drill holes sampled in the present study (Lisheen mine, 1998).

 

Figure 006704
View larger version (81K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 4. North-south cross section through the Derryville zone, showing major lithological units and location of main ore lens (Lisheen mine, 1998).

 

Figure 007005
View larger version (16K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 5. Summary paragenesis for the Lisheen deposit (after Eyre, 1998). Width of bar corresponds to relative abundance; bars for sulfides are shown hatched for clarity.

 

Figure 007106
View larger version (91K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 6. Core photographs and reflected light photomicrographs of preore-stage samples. (a). Preore-stage pyrite preferentially replacing the matrix of typical black dolomite matrix breccia. Sample LK262/153.6m, Derryville zone. (b). Pale-brown early sphalerite preferentially replacing matrix of dolomite breccia. Sample LK121-189.3m, Main zone. (c). Preore-stage colloform pyrite with minor carbonate and sphalerite inclusions overgrown by subhedral pyrite (py) and marcasite (ma). Sample LK420/190.7m, Derryville zone. (d). Fine-grained granular pyrite (py) pseudomorphous after barite laths. Timing of euhedral pyrite uncertain. Subhedral-anhedral sphalerite (sp) overgrows and replaces pyrite. Sample LK262/162.1m, Derryville zone. (e). Massive sulfide sample showing colloform banding. Preore-stage fine-grained pyrite-marcasite (py-ma) with sphalerite-rich outer zone is overgrown by pyrite-marcasite band, itself succeeded and partly replaced by ore-stage sphalerite (sp), dolomite (dol), and euhedral galena (gn). Sample LK394/164.3m, Derryville zone (Derryville fault). (f). Preore-stage massive pyrite (py) and marcasite (ma) that has undergone cataclasis and cementation by dolomite (dol) and sphalerite (sp). Sample LK262/159.1m, Derryville zone.

 

Figure 007207
View larger version (98K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 7. Core photographs and reflected light photomicrographs of main ore-stage samples. (a). Massive fine-grained pyrite in gray Waulsortian micrite (m), crosscut and replaced by sphalerite (sp) and galena (gn) in white dolomite stockwork. Sample LK121/190.2m, Main zone. (b). Complex massive sulfide with pyrite (py) intergrown with and replaced by galena (gn) and pale-brown sphalerite (sp). Note apparent breccia texture (replaced dolomite breccia?). Sample LK262/159.85m, Derryville zone. (c). Colloform sphalerite containing thin bands of fine-grained pyrite and occasional botryoidal pyrite intergrown with dolomite and fine-grained, zinc-rich (?geopetal) carbonate. Sample LK262/159.85m, Derryville zone. (d). Pyrite (py) and sphalerite (sp) incorporated in dolomite (dol) euhedra along growth surfaces and overgrown by apparently homogeneous colloform sphalerite. Sample LK416/193.6m, Derryville zone. (e). Selective replacement of foraminifera (Endothyrid). Sphalerite (sp) preferentially replaces chamber walls with chambers filled by galena (gn) and carbonate gangue (c), the whole surrounded by pyrite (py). An unidentified Fe-As sulfide (u) with minor Ni, Co, and In forms a thin layer inside the microfossil. Sample LK137/134.9m, Derryville zone (sub-Waulsortian, footwall of Derryville fault). (f). Mixed ore-stage sulfide assemblage comprising intergrown euhedral pyrite (py) and galena (gn), together with sphalerite (sp), probably pseudomorphous after barite laths. Sample LK325/146.2m, Derryville zone. (g). Selective replacement of ooid by galena (gn), surrounded and partly replaced by sphalerite (sp) and minor pyrite (py). Galena replacement may postdate plastic deformation of ooid reflected by oval shape and curviplanar contacts that parallel distorted laminae (upper right). No replaced stylolites truncating laminae, or fractured, or spalled laminae are observed indicating replacement preceded mechanical compaction, or that mechanical compaction did not occur. Sample LK394/164.3m, Derryville zone (Derryville fault). (h). Symmetrical vug-fill sulfides comprising sphalerite (sp) intergrown with laminated and/or colloform pyrite (py), with both being replaced from the margins inward by subhedral galena (gn). Carbonate infilling in remaining space (c), with minor dissolution of sphalerite along contact. Sample LK420/196.0m, Derryville zone.

 

Figure 007408
View larger version (9K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 8. Examples of variations in chemical composition of sphalerite as determined by microprobe analyses (supplementary information on detection limits and full data available from author on request). (a). Traverse across main ore-stage color-banded colloform sphalerite (sample 262/159.1m, Derryville zone). Note lack of correlation between element concentrations in individual bands and occasional detectable Cu. (b). Traverse across late ore-stage finely crystalline, red-amber color-zoned sphalerite (sample 471/210.4m, Main zone). This sample is unusual in that it shows elevated Cd and Fe and shows a rare correlation between Cd and Fe concentrations.

 

Figure 007409
View larger version (31K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 9. Variation of cadmium and iron concentrations in sphalerite as a function of textural type and location. Note that the vast majority of samples are enriched in either cadmium or sphalerite, but not both, suggesting substitution of one or other element into the same lattice site. Darker brown sphalerite may be either Cd or Fe rich. The most Cd rich sphalerites are hosted by the Lisduff Oolite; Fe-rich sphalerites are generally from within the main fault zones. Most sphalerite in the main orebodies (within thick hatched line) contains variable Fe and low Cd.

 

Figure 007510
View larger version (12K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 10. Histograms of sulfur isotope compositions, subdivided according to (a) sulfide phase and (b) ore stage. Sphalerite and galena have very similar ranges and average values, whereas pyrite is much more variable and trends to much lower {delta}34S values. Preore sulfides (mainly pyrite) are characterized by very low {delta}34S values indicative of an extreme bacteriogenic fractionation. Main ore-stage values are intermediate due to mixing between bacteriogenic and hydrothermal sulfur sources coupled with less extreme bacteriogenic fractionation during sulfate reduction. Late ore-stage sulfides are dominated by hydrothermal sulfur with high {delta}34S. Postore-stage sulfides have low {delta}34S values, probably indicative of sulfur remobilized from early main ore-stage sulfides.

 

Figure 007511
View larger version (20K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 11. Variations in sulfur isotope composition of (a) sphalerite, (b) galena, and (c) pyrite with depth and textural type. Outliers: BZ = Bog zone, DZ = Derryville zone, MZ = Main zone, NZ = North zone. Samples from sub-Waulsortian units are indicated. Sphalerite and galena show trends toward higher {delta}34S values with depth in the main ore zones and in sub-Waulsortian sulfides consistent with input of an 34S-enriched sulfur component from depth. Pyrite does not show such a trend in the main ore zones, suggesting that much of it formed relatively early when the flux of hydrothermal sulfur from depth was minor or absent.

 

Figure 007612
View larger version (17K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 12. 207Pb/204Pb vs. 206Pb/204Pb plot, showing lead isotope compositions of galena from Lisheen (this study) with error bars, compared to deposit array (encompasses average values for all Irish deposits and prospects) and average Silvermines value (see Table 3). Lisheen data fall close to the Silvermines average, implying a common lead source from local lower Paleozoic rocks. Pb growth curve of Stacey and Kramers (1975) is marked in 250 Ma increments for reference.

 

Figure 007713
View larger version (8K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 13. Range of cadmium concentrations in sphalerite samples (determined by microprobe analysis) plotted against sulfur isotope composition. A weak positive correlation exists, suggesting that cadmium is associated with the hydrothermal sulfur component, both being derived from the lower Paleozoic basement.

 

Figure 007914
View larger version (42K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 14. Spatial variations in sulfur isotope composition of sphalerite and galena from the main and late ore stages at Lisheen. Average values for multiple analyses from each drill hole sampled are shown. Main ore-stage {delta}34S values are subdivided into those dominated by bacteriogenic sulfur (plain numbers) and those with an inferred hydrothermal sulfur component ({delta}34S > –7{per thousand}), shown in gray boxes. Late to postore-stage values are shown in black boxes. Higher values for both main- and late ore-stage sulfides are observed near the main east-west–trending faults and/or northwest-trending structures, suggesting that these are the main conduits for fluids transporting hydrothermal sulfur from depth. Two principal subvertical conduits for hydrothermal fluid ingress into the ore zones are suggested, one in the east Main zone and one in the west Derryville zone.

 

Figure 008015
View larger version (68K):

[in a new window]
 
FIG. 15. Model for mineralization at Lisheen. (a). Stage 1: Preore dolomitization. Early diagenetic regional dolomitization of the Waulsortian Limestone driven by brine reflux from the shelf area bordering the Leinster massif predated or may have been partly synchronous with brecciation of the Waulsortian Limestone. Lisheen is located at the northwestern fringe of a zone of pervasive dolomitization, probably close to a shelf basin break controlled by propagation of Caledonian basement structures up into the overlying cover in the late Courceyan. (b). Stage 2: Fluid flow into the ore-forming environment. The high intergranular matrix porosity developed as a result of synsedimentary and/or the onset of hydrothermal brecciation was a critical ground preparation, producing a permeable lithology into which later mineralizing fluids were focused. Brecciation coupled with sufficient development of fault-related permeability resulted in connectivity between the two main fluid reservoirs (deep hydrothermal and shallow H2S-rich brine). This allowed the two fluids to penetrate into, and mix within, the breccia units. Alteration and stripping of Cu, As, Co, and Ni from the Old Red Sandstone adjacent to the main east-west–trending fault array was likely the result of focusing and upward flow of relatively reduced lower Paleozoic-equilibrated metal-bearing fluids within fault-related damage zones. Flow into the basal Waulsortian breccias was via the main Lisheen fault array and northwest-trending faults in the hanging wall. Downward flow of low-temperature saline brines occurred by migration down the upper parts of the Lisheen fault array or laterally along stratigraphy, within the dolomitized Waulsortian, the Lisduff Oolite, and also possibly along the regional dolomite front. Brine flow could have been driven by local convection induced by thermal anomalies associated with the upwelling, high-temperature fluids or by simple density contrast. (c). Stage 3: Fluid mixing. The onset of fluid mixing within the breccias led to rapid precipitation of sulfides in isotopic disequilibrium in any available pore space. Acid generated by sulfide deposition enabled dolomite dissolution, thereby creating additional porosity. The volume reduction associated with dolomite replacement by sulfide could have caused as much as a 25 percent increase in porosity, enabling further mixing and ore deposition. This, together with the elevated initial porosity and nonstoichiometry of the matrix dolomite, may explain why the lithology was such a favorable host rock to ore. Abundant evidence for multiple stages of sulfide deposition, reworking, and brecciation suggests a protracted evolution of the system in tandem with active faulting. Zone-refining processes may have led to some of the metal zonation and textural complexity observed. White matrix breccia may have developed above the ore zones due to limited downward collapse caused by the volume loss associated with sulfide replacement. (d). Stage 4: Hydrothermal sealing and progressive burial. Sulfur isotope data suggest that mineralization terminated due to exhaustion of the main H2S source and brine reservoir or blocking of brine infiltration pathways, possibly by deposition of supra-Waulsortian argillaceous sediments. The late ore stage involved choking of residual porosity by precipitation of calcite, dolomite, and sulfides from the principal ore fluid alone. Sulfide deposition at this time was probably driven by simple cooling. The late-stage calcite (C4) and dolomite (D4) veins and breccias may reflect overpressuring of the principal ore fluid in the main-flow conduits caused by progressive burial and hydrothermal sealing. A late overprint by low-temperature, high-salinity fluids resulted in remobilization of preore or main ore-stage sulfides and precipitation of D5 pink dolomite. It is suggested that these fluids represent evolved basin formation waters, mobilized as a result of the onset of Variscan compression to the south of Ireland in the Mid- to Late Carboniferous.

 





JOURNAL HOME HELP CONTACT PUBLISHER SUBSCRIBE ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS
Copyright © 2008 by Society of Economic Geologists